Pizza cravings hit hard—but nothing’s worse than getting a slice that’s just… meh. If you’ve ever typed best pizza Salem MA into Google and ended up disappointed, you’re not alone. With so many pizza places in Salem, finding the one that truly satisfies can feel like a gamble. That’s why we did the work for you—ranking the top 8 pizza spots in town based on what really matters: flavor, crust, and sauce. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, here’s where your next great pizza night starts.
Top 8 Best Pizza Salem MA Spots You Need to Try
1. PZA Pizza Salem – The Local Favorite That Gets It All Right
Flavor Score: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Crust: Crispy on the outside, soft in the center
Sauce: Tangy, fresh, and balanced
PZA Pizza Salem isn’t just another pizza joint—it’s a place where attention to detail shows in every bite. Their dough is made fresh, the sauce is slow-cooked with real tomatoes, and toppings are always generous. The balance of sweet and savory in their signature red sauce makes every slice pop. Plus, whether you’re into thin-crust or classic hand-tossed, they’ve got you covered.
PZA doesn’t try too hard—it just nails the essentials. That’s why locals keep coming back, and why it tops this list for best pizza Salem MA.
2. Bambolina
Flavor Score: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆
Crust: Authentic Neapolitan-style, lightly charred
Sauce: San Marzano tomatoes, smooth and bright
Bambolina is known for its wood-fired pizza and minimalist approach. The focus here is on high-quality ingredients and traditional preparation. Their pizzas cook in just about 90 seconds in a blazing oven, which gives the crust a perfect blister. While the topping options are more artisanal, the flavor still hits home. If you’re a fan of thin, chewy Neapolitan-style pies, Bambolina is worth a visit.
3. Essex’s NY Pizza & Deli
Flavor Score: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆
Crust: Thin, foldable, and classic NYC-style
Sauce: Slightly sweet with a peppery finish
Craving a New York slice in Massachusetts? This spot brings it. Essex’s delivers on that thin, greasy, fold-it-in-half slice that defines NYC pizza. While it might not win awards for artisanal toppings, it hits all the nostalgic notes—and sometimes, that’s exactly what you want. Fast service, large portions, and honest pizza make this one of the top pizza places in Salem.
4. Flying Saucer Pizza Company
Flavor Score: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆
Crust: Chewy, pan-style
Sauce: Slightly zesty, bold with garlic undertones
With sci-fi themed pies and a laid-back vibe, Flying Saucer Pizza brings a bit of fun to the Salem pizza scene. But don’t let the novelty fool you—their food is legit. Their dough is thick but not heavy, and the sauces have depth. Vegetarian and vegan options are strong here too, with creative toppings and dairy-free cheese that still satisfies.
5. Antonio’s Pizza by the Slice
Flavor Score: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆
Crust: Slightly crispy, great for reheating
Sauce: Simple, not too sweet
Antonio’s wins big on variety. You can try 15+ different slices without committing to a whole pie, which makes it perfect for indecisive eaters. It’s ideal for lunch breaks or late-night cravings. While it doesn’t specialize in gourmet pizza, the rotation of flavors (think mac & cheese pizza or chicken bacon ranch) makes it a go-to for Salem college students and anyone looking for bold variety.
6. Boston Pizza & Seafood – from the Best Pizza Salem MA
Flavor Score: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆
Crust: Firm, a little chewy
Sauce: Hearty and slightly sweet
Don’t be thrown off by the name—Boston Pizza & Seafood in Salem serves surprisingly solid pizza. The crust holds up well to heavier toppings like meat lovers and buffalo chicken. Their red sauce has a thicker texture, perfect for folks who like a heartier slice.
Bonus: If you’re with someone who’s not feeling pizza, their seafood and subs are also pretty good.
7. Engine House Pizza
Flavor Score: ⭐⭐⭐☆
Crust: Fluffy and thick
Sauce: Mild, family-friendly
This one’s more of a hidden gem. Engine House has been around for decades, and its pizza feels like something you’d get at a weekend family party. The crust is doughier and softer, making it more filling. It’s not fancy, but it’s dependable. If you’re after something classic and simple, Engine House fits the bill. A solid option among neighborhood pizza spots in Salem.
8. A & B Burgers (Pizza Nights Only)
Flavor Score: ⭐⭐⭐☆
Crust: Crunchy edge, airy inside
Sauce: Slightly tangy, pairs well with cheese
Okay, technically not a full-time pizzeria—but when A & B runs pizza specials, they’re worth checking out. You can tell their chefs care about flavor balance. It’s not the most consistent option (since it’s not always on the menu), but when they offer it, the crust and sauce hit the mark. Think of it as a great wildcard pick.
Which Pizza Place Should You Try First?
If you’re looking for all-around excellence—where the flavor, crust, and sauce come together seamlessly—PZA Pizza Salem stands out. It’s the kind of place where you can bring picky eaters, foodies, and classic cheese lovers, and everyone leaves happy. In a city full of pizza choices, that kind of consistency means everythingIn a city full of pizza places in Salem, that kind of consistency means everything.
So the next time you’re typing best pizza Salem, MA into your search bar, remember this list. Great pizza doesn’t have to be a gamble.
🍕 Looking for the best pizza Salem MA locals swear by?
Taste the difference at PZA Pizza Salem—your new favorite spot for flavor, freshness, and local charm.
